Oil leak - mechanic 'fixed' something else

Asked by Apr 02, 2017 at 02:11 PM about the 2006 Volkswagen Beetle 2.5L PZEV

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

Please help. I bought a used 2006
Volkswagen New Beetle with tiptronic a
year ago. I had it inspected at a
Volkswagen dealership prior to purchase
and they said it had a small oil leak coming
from the vaccum pump. I purchased the
vehicle and noticed that it dripped
approximately 1 drop of oil every day. I
took the car in for an unrelated repair two
weeks ago (interior light issue) and the
mechanic I took it to noted the oil leak. I
said yes I was aware of it, told him that the
pre-purchase inspection had indicated it
was coming from the vaccum pump, and
asked him to tell me what it would cost to
fix it. He said they would check it out and
let me know. He came back and said I
needed to replace the oil pan and the oil
filter and said it would cost over $900.00. I
agreed to the repair since I don't know
anything about cars or oil leaks and paid
for it. A week later I noticed new oil spots
in the same spot on the driveway. I took it
back to the shop and the mechanic said
there must be another oil leak that needs
fixed. He changed the oil filter (again), put
in some dye, told me to drive it 100 miles
and bring it back for inspection. I suspect
the he originally misdiagnosed the oil leak
and replaced stuff that didn't need
replaced but I have no idea how to prove
that.  So of course now he wants to charge
me to fix this 'other' leak which is what I
asked him to fix to begin with. On top of
that, the car is now leaking more oil than it
was before. Before I would see maybe 1
drop of oil per day, now I'm seeing 3"-4"
spots - I took a picture of the driveway
where you can see a YEAR's worth of
small drops and then the most recent,
much larger ones. I don't know what to do.

1 Answer

For clarification: the repair order for the first $900.00 'repair' that the shop did says "Remove & replace oil pan &/or gasket - lower oil pan gasket (engine)" and "Remove & replace oil filter flange &/or gasket oil cooler gasket".

Your Answer

Volkswagen Beetle Experts

  • #1
    tenspeed
    Reputation
    1,780
  • #2
    Chris Billings
    Reputation
    1,550
  • #3
    Tom Demyan
    Reputation
    1,350
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used MINI Cooper
50 Great Deals out of 584 listings starting at $1,993
Used Volkswagen Jetta
102 Great Deals out of 2,201 listings starting at $1,200
Used Jeep Wrangler
110 Great Deals out of 1,641 listings starting at $3,995
Used Honda Civic
297 Great Deals out of 3,465 listings starting at $995
Used Ford Mustang
9 Great Deals out of 1,138 listings starting at $1,250
Used Volkswagen Golf
67 Great Deals out of 812 listings starting at $2,295
Used Honda Accord
81 Great Deals out of 1,074 listings starting at $1,200
Used Volkswagen Eos
59 listings starting at $6,888
Used Toyota Corolla
181 Great Deals out of 3,731 listings starting at $2,245
Used Volkswagen GTI
34 Great Deals out of 185 listings starting at $3,400
Used Volkswagen Passat
24 Great Deals out of 519 listings starting at $2,500
Used Toyota Camry
62 Great Deals out of 1,933 listings starting at $850

Used Cars For Sale

2017 Volkswagen Beetle For Sale
5 Great Deals out of 69 listings starting at $18,588
2016 Volkswagen Beetle For Sale
17 Great Deals out of 56 listings starting at $15,995
2015 Volkswagen Beetle For Sale
10 Great Deals out of 30 listings starting at $14,995
2014 Volkswagen Beetle For Sale
26 listings starting at $14,495
2013 Volkswagen Beetle For Sale
41 listings starting at $12,481

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use.