2012 Subaru Forester - Engine replacement or time to say goodbye

Asked by Aug 19, 2019 at 08:01 PM about the 2012 Subaru Forester

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

Hello - in the middle of a cross country move, and my 2012 Subaru Forester
started knocking. Dropped it at the dealership today and they say the oil was
low and there are metal shavings in the oil. The last oil change was less than
500 miles ago, and the dealership where I am moving from found no issues -
I've not noticed any oil puddles under the car, and it doesn't have a history of
oil loss like this. The dealership (where I'm stuck right now) couldn't tell me
why this has happened.

We still have about an 800 mile drive before we get to our final destination.

I'm waiting on a quote for a rebuilt engine, but have no idea what the issue
is. The car has over 200,000 miles on it. Would you replace the engine with
a rebuilt or would you trade? How long can you expect a rebuilt engine to
last? I know it's all a best guess, just looking for some opinions while I'm
waiting. Thank you!

2 Answers

Dylan. I had the SAME THING HAPPEN TO ME. Just moved to MT, took my 2012 Subaru Forester, with a fresh oil change across the country. Made it 3 hours from my destination and the knocking started which within a minute turned into full blown engine failure. Got stranded for a bit. Left the car behind at a Subaru dealership for now. Can't do anything at the moment. This should NOT happen to a Subaru customer. I have 120,000 miles on the car. I was taken advantage of my lack of Subaru knowledge at the car shop. They didn't tell me about the oil consumption problem. I had to find out myself and stay on top of it. Not sure what to do. Engine replacement is expensive. Not sure if I should replace it, and invest in a 7 year old car with no other issues. Or just buy a junker.

Finding your postings about the 2012 Subaru Forester was interesting. I bought this car for my son, who took drove it about 600 miles to work at a summer camp. A month later, on the way back to Ohio, the car was making a knocking sound and before my son could get to a safe place to pull over, the engine was shot. I had to bus my son home but the car is still in PA. I still owe $8K so I have to fix it. Learning this particular engine has an oil consumption issue is frustrating because this problem will still be there even if engine is replaced. There was even a lawsuit against Subaru which granted consumers an additional 30k miles on their warranty. I don’t know what to do. I’m so angry and frustrated. I chose Subaru for my son because of their reputation for longevity and safety. That was a mistake.

Your Answer:

CarGurus Experts

  • #1
  • #2
    Chris W
  • #3
    Nick Eidemiller
View All

Find great deals from top-rated dealers


Related Models For Sale

Used Subaru Outback
66 Great Deals out of 1,211 listings starting at $4,995
Used Toyota RAV4
117 Great Deals out of 4,862 listings starting at $3,900
Used Honda CR-V
145 Great Deals out of 6,064 listings starting at $2,639
Used Subaru Impreza
44 Great Deals out of 904 listings starting at $2,490
Used Subaru Legacy
17 Great Deals out of 416 listings starting at $3,499
Used Toyota 4Runner
33 Great Deals out of 1,007 listings starting at $4,999
Used Ford Escape
204 Great Deals out of 6,571 listings starting at $2,750
Used Mazda CX-5
61 Great Deals out of 3,450 listings starting at $6,999
Used Toyota Highlander
58 Great Deals out of 1,370 listings starting at $4,907
Used Nissan Rogue
185 Great Deals out of 6,797 listings starting at $140
Used Toyota Tacoma
53 Great Deals out of 2,114 listings starting at $6,200
Used Subaru XV Crosstrek
6 Great Deals out of 163 listings starting at $7,900
Used Honda Pilot
53 Great Deals out of 1,811 listings starting at $4,960

Used Cars for Sale

2019 Subaru Forester For Sale
16 Great Deals out of 248 listings starting at $25,995
2018 Subaru Forester For Sale
48 listings starting at $18,995
2017 Subaru Forester For Sale
7 Great Deals out of 146 listings starting at $14,989
2016 Subaru Forester For Sale
5 Great Deals out of 115 listings starting at $13,274
2015 Subaru Forester For Sale
5 Great Deals out of 111 listings starting at $7,880

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use. Content will be removed if CarGurus becomes aware that it violates our policies.